Gareth Lock is the inspirational founder of The Human Diver. On leaving his 25-year career in the RAF he was already an experienced diver having started to learn the sport in 1999. His very first dive took place in Greece while on holiday. However, it was while on work trips to Cape Town and San Diego that he knew diving would become an important part of his life.
As he became more experienced in diving, he realised that it was all about teamwork and there’s one thing the military do very well – working as a team. They know through extensive training and experience in the theatre of war that little mistakes around behaviour, poor decisions, lack of situational awareness and complacency costs lives.
Sadly, Gareth found that often in diving that holistic ethos was lacking. Teams were not always led well, did not get on with each other and members often operated in separate silos without any consideration for those also sharing that diving experience. Dysfunctional teams were often left to cope by instructors who had become complacent and disconnected. Much training focused on technical expertise – which is critically important – yet didn’t touch on the equal importance of human behaviour and team development.
Gareth decided to do something about it and has set himself a mission of introducing human factors training into the diving profession globally. It’s not always easy. There has been resistance to his systems-based approach. However, he’s remained committed and has travelled the world sharing his story.
The Human Diver on Facebook
The Human Diver on Instagram
The Human Diver on Twitter
Gareth's website: The Human Diver
Gareth's book: Under Pressure
Thanks for listening legends!
If you've enjoyed this episode and more, we would LOVE a ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ review via iTunes or your favourite streaming platform. It all helps with promoting the show.
☎️ We also appreciate any feedback, especially if you have topics or people you would like to hear on the show. Simply leave us a comment, use the contact form or flick us a DM
VIP - Would you like to join us on a dive trip? If the answer is yes, use the contact form, leave your details and tell us to add you to the list.
00:00:04
Matt: Podcast for the inquisitive diver. Hey there, dive buddies
00:00:07
and welcome to the show. My next guest has served 25 years in the
00:00:11
Royal air force and fell in love with the sport of diving way back
00:00:14
in 1999, he recognized that there was a significant similarity
00:00:18
between life as a military man and that of a diver teamwork.
00:00:22
However, there was an even more significant difference between
00:00:25
the two when compared through the holistic ethos lens, he decided
00:00:29
to do something about this and same self, a mission to
00:00:31
introducing human factors, training into the diving
00:00:34
profession globally. In 2019, he released a book entitled under
00:00:39
pressure, which has since sold thousands of copies. Now I have
00:00:43
to admit that I respect and admire him for his brave
00:00:45
contributions to the dive industry. And I say brave, not
00:00:48
because I'm admitting a macro shuttle rather than I recognize
00:00:51
that difficulties and individual may face in attempting to create
00:00:54
change, even when it is for the betterment of all involved. I
00:00:59
honestly believe that what he has done so far will most definitely
00:01:01
save lives and probably already has done. So, Mr. Gareth Locke,
00:01:05
it's an absolute pleasure to meet you. Welcome to the show.
00:01:08
Gareth: Thank you very much. Really appreciate it. It says
00:01:11
great to have an invite on here and yeah, it has been a challenge
00:01:15
and has required a significant amount of persistence to, to get
00:01:20
this girl.
00:01:20
Matt: Yeah, I bet. So, um, w w was it a little bit like a red
00:01:25
flag football or something to you ? Like a little Jack Russell just
00:01:27
chomping at the heels?
00:01:28
Gareth: Well, my, my sort of personality traits are about sort
00:01:32
of values based and it's like, I've got to get this done. And,
00:01:36
and that actually has been a bit of a hindrance when I first
00:01:39
started, because it was this, uh , evangelical approach of you
00:01:45
have to change and, and a few people off and burnt a few
00:01:49
bridges and took a number of years to, to rebuild those. Um,
00:01:55
and I think that's the same with anybody. Who's got a strong value
00:01:59
based. Who's trying to create change. It's, it's tempering
00:02:04
that, that attitude to look for the long game, rather than trying
00:02:09
to do something. Now, you're never going to change the
00:02:13
direction of, uh, uh, you know, saying iceberg, you know, the one
00:02:15
that's broken off the Antarctica, you're never going to change that
00:02:19
direction really easily. Um, it takes little nudges and actually
00:02:26
where I've had the biggest successes is bottom up rather
00:02:30
than top down. Um, because there are people at the bottom who
00:02:34
recognize actually this is really useful, knowledgeable stuff that
00:02:39
as you say will, and I already know that with people, who've
00:02:43
emailed me saying, you know what? I listened to, you know, a
00:02:47
webinar or a podcast, or read something of yours or watch their
00:02:50
phone only. And that's changed my attitude as to how, um, how I've
00:02:58
approached a and I've thumbed it early, uh, or I've not got in, or
00:03:02
I've changed what we were going to do. And to me, that that's a
00:03:06
huge, huge buzz because it's like, yes, you know, the, the
00:03:12
changing one person at a time is , uh, this is how you can change
00:03:16
the world. Yeah. It takes a long time.
00:03:19
Matt: Well, you've got to start somewhere and then just spread
00:03:21
the legs. Um, now just to back it up, uh, we smudge for those
00:03:26
people that are listening that have no clue what human factors
00:03:29
is. Do you want to try and break it down into its most simplistic
00:03:32
form? Just so we've got a basis to go from. Yeah,
00:03:35
Gareth: Yeah, yeah, sure. So in its simplest term, it is how to
00:03:41
make it easier to do the right thing and harder to do the wrong
00:03:45
thing. And that means looking at individuals, it means looking at
00:03:52
work or tasks, and he's looking at equipment, it means looking at
00:03:56
interactions and paperwork and understand how to reduce the
00:04:02
friction to do the right thing. So for example, you know,
00:04:06
checklists are a big thing in diving at moments. And then when
00:04:10
you look at how they're written, they're often sweeping
00:04:14
generalization here, a written from a point of view of liability
00:04:20
rather than execution. So there's a huge body of evidence that
00:04:24
says, how do you design a checklist that takes human
00:04:28
performance variability that could be errors, um, and try to
00:04:34
design them out and a checklist. Isn't just a piece of paper floor
00:04:39
. It doesn't, it's not just a piece of paper to make it
00:04:41
effective. It requires a social and a cultural setup and a mental
00:04:46
approach that says I'm using this checklist because I'm fallible
00:04:50
and I will make a mistake and it's getting that message across.
00:04:55
So there's a whole raft of issues that, that need to be addressed
00:05:00
in a, as you sort of touched on earlier holistic manner or
00:05:03
systemic way, rather than trying to cherry pick or fix the diver.
00:05:10
Cause they're there, the stupid ones is actually creating an
00:05:14
environment where it's easier to do the right thing and harder to
00:05:17
do the wrong thing. Yeah.
00:05:18
Matt: Yeah. And I suppose one of the major barriers that you've
00:05:21
got there is, um, piece of people's personal feelings of
00:05:24
embarrassment. If they're going to thumb a dive when everyone
00:05:27
else has more confident or more experienced, whatever,
00:05:31
Gareth: Oh, totally. That, you know, the peer pressure that
00:05:34
we're under and the, you know, ultimately we're social
00:05:37
creatures. We, we like to be conform to the social norms. And,
00:05:43
and that's why, you know, you can start to create change at a lower
00:05:48
level with individuals and small groups, because then you can
00:05:52
start to get a swelling it's quite difficult to create change
00:05:55
top down because you still need to create that, that swell, that,
00:06:01
that, that influence and social conformance that happens. But you
00:06:05
know, that that sort of peer pressure, it might be touched on
00:06:09
in, in diver training and instructor development. But I
00:06:13
don't think it's anywhere near emphasized how much influence
00:06:18
instructors leaders and peers have on others' behaviors. And
00:06:24
you don't have to say something almost silence is enough to speak
00:06:29
volumes. Um, when somebody questions is this a good idea?
00:06:34
And I, nobody even acknowledges that, that, you know, Oh, I'm not
00:06:38
sure about this Barbie. Okay. And you haven't actually said
00:06:41
anything or you've just agreed with them. Um, so there's,
00:06:46
there's a huge bit that that looks at, or that should be
00:06:50
looked at in terms of interactions.
00:06:53
Matt: Hmm. So the idea behind the training that you provide is to
00:06:58
teach people not only how to recognize it in themselves, but
00:07:02
have the confidence to be able to say so, and also recognize it in
00:07:06
other people within the group that I'm in with.
00:07:09
Gareth: Yeah, totally. I mean, and actually the core of the
00:07:11
training is based around the premise of creating a shared
00:07:17
mental model and an idea of what we're going to do as a team and
00:07:23
why are we going to do it? And that means that if there is some
00:07:28
form of dissent, you know, which is a good thing or some conflict
00:07:32
that the, the peers and the leadership have created
00:07:35
environment where actually you don't need to have courage. Um,
00:07:40
there's often this bit of people, you know, that you need to be
00:07:42
brave to speak up. This level of bravery is needed to overcome
00:07:47
some fear. And the fear is generated by the social
00:07:52
environment that the leaders, the instructors, the peer group that
00:07:55
are there and therefore it's their responsibility to change
00:07:59
that attitude, that, that, uh, environment, so that it is easy
00:08:06
to speak up rather than having to be brave and go, well, I'm going
00:08:10
to put my neck out on the line here because I'm going to say
00:08:13
something that isn't quite right. Um, so it's, yeah, there's a lot
00:08:17
to do. And that is a normal human thing. Um, because we are, if we
00:08:23
go back, you know, thousands of years to the African Savannah,
00:08:28
where you lived in a tribe in a thorn Bush ring, because that was
00:08:33
the protection from the lines, Hey, you had to be conformed to
00:08:38
the norms of the group because as long as you got booted out,
00:08:42
outside the phone book and you're on your own, so there are very
00:08:48
good reasons why we have social conformance, whether or not there
00:08:53
is as valid as they are, is a different thing, but you know,
00:08:57
it's hardwired. So yeah, the training is, is create that
00:09:00
shared mental model so that people know what's happening
00:09:02
next. And if something deviates, then they're able to sort of ask
00:09:07
the question and say, is this right? Are we going in the right
00:09:10
direction? Is this the right part of the wreck? Shouldn't we have
00:09:13
turned round on the reef at this point, you know, it's, there,
00:09:17
there are lots of things where, where this applies. Hmm.
00:09:21
Matt: So when we're talking about it straight away, I'm thinking
00:09:24
about a blog that I wrote about three years ago. And then I was
00:09:28
trying to describe, um, newcomers to the dive and industry or those
00:09:34
that want to do that open water training. And the two examples I
00:09:38
had was the alpha male who, you know, really big. I can do all
00:09:44
this and don't need to listen. And, uh, the timid lady, you
00:09:49
know, who would just focus and then do and do everything
00:09:53
correct. And for me, the human factor error all the way I see it
00:09:59
though, is that Mr. Belli big, the alpha male, um, was, was hide
00:10:05
in his true, um, fears and incompetencies of what was
00:10:11
coming. And I think it does make me look towards the, uh,
00:10:19
professional side of dive in and ask the question if there's been
00:10:25
people qualified to hastily too quickly and, you know, thinking
00:10:30
of zero to hero. And then all of a sudden, you're now teaching
00:10:33
people who have no clue how to dive in a wide variety of, um,
00:10:39
scenarios. Um, I suppose you bring in human factors into it
00:10:46
kind of puts a big question, Mark all over all of that stuff that
00:10:50
the majority of us in the dive industry know it occurs, but
00:10:55
don't really approach the subject.
00:10:58
Gareth: Yeah. It it's, um, it is a bit of an elephant in the room.
00:11:03
And so going to, to a wider sort of safety view as to why that
00:11:09
perception exists of why the current practices are okay, a lot
00:11:15
of safety is measured as the absence of accidents. So if you
00:11:21
don't have any accidents and we don't have any injuries, um, we
00:11:26
must be doing something right now that doesn't take into account
00:11:30
the number of people who are scared, um, who go off and do
00:11:34
some training and an, a terrified , um, they they've got that tick
00:11:40
and they've moved on and gone. I went diving, but I didn't like
00:11:43
it. And yet there shouldn't be a reason for that. Yes, there will
00:11:46
be a small percentage who are, um , not suited to diving and, you
00:11:51
know, and they aren't, um, being the right mental place to be
00:11:55
underwater. So, you know, you then look at, so the sort of why
00:12:02
the situation ends up as it is, is because you can cut away the
00:12:07
safety margins, the experience, the time that people are supposed
00:12:13
to do during training. And until you have lots of accidents, you
00:12:17
must be doing something. Okay. And again, that's normal human
00:12:20
behavior. We will look for short term gains over waiting for
00:12:28
long-term benefits. Um, and, and in the case of, of diving and
00:12:32
instruction and the zero, the hero of it is cool. I get to be a
00:12:35
dive instructor. And I, I, you know, I get to make money out of
00:12:39
my hobby. Um, and you're right. That as long as, as long as the
00:12:46
training environment in which the students are being taught is not
00:12:52
very, um, risky, you know, that there's no additional Jake
00:12:57
dangers involved and everything goes fine. That actually the
00:13:01
training must have been okay. The problem is we don't know what's
00:13:05
going to happen on the, on the dive or with a student. And so
00:13:10
actually you need to have a, almost a bigger box. You've got
00:13:13
the, sort of the core competencies or core skills that
00:13:18
you need. And then there's the bit that says, sit a bit further
00:13:22
out than that, that says these there excursions that you might
00:13:25
have. And my, you know, my personal view is a lot of diver
00:13:31
instructor training is teaching instructors how to teach a
00:13:35
student how to pass a class, which is not the same as how to
00:13:40
teach a diver, how to dive in the real world. Um, and, and if your
00:13:45
measure is, is people graduating well, w without issues, you must
00:13:49
be doing something right. Um,
00:13:52
Matt: Yeah. And that inherent skill embedded into second
00:13:56
nature.
00:13:58
Gareth: Yeah. And they get out of jail card for the organizations
00:14:01
is you are only, uh, certified to dive in conditions equal to
00:14:07
better than you've already been certified. Um, so that, that's
00:14:12
the bit that says, well, actually, you, you went diving in
00:14:14
the condition that you weren't trained for. Therefore, it's your
00:14:16
fault. It's like, well, hang on a minute. You know, you've got to
00:14:20
look at this at a system level rather than an individual level.
00:14:25
Matt: Yeah. But what, where does the system start and stop for
00:14:29
you? Because I was kind of discussing this podcast before we
00:14:35
started a, a couple of days ago. Actually, I've got a buddy of
00:14:38
mine coming on next week. I Steinback, no, look, I, um, he's
00:14:42
a cost director up in Cairns. And I wanted to clarify for myself,
00:14:45
albeit I am a multi-agency instructor. I wanted to know
00:14:49
specifically where the law starts and stops when it comes to
00:14:54
training. And it's so ambiguous, isn't it? And he, his answer was
00:15:02
literally when that, when people are in training, then you have to
00:15:07
follow the letter of the law. And the letter of the law is written
00:15:09
by whichever agency is teaching and whichever agency you're
00:15:13
teaching under. But as soon as that person is qualified and they
00:15:16
go off on their own, there's then no law that says a diver can't do
00:15:21
what they want. Um, so as soon as they are outside the boundaries
00:15:26
of what they've been taught, then, you know, the agencies are
00:15:28
safe.
00:15:30
Gareth: Oh, totally. And you know, the way that risk is
00:15:33
managed is all about risk transference. So from an eight,
00:15:39
you know, if I look at, so you ask the question, where's the
00:15:41
boundary of the system that this to me, the system starts at the
00:15:47
agency's level, or actually the bodies above. So the rebury, the
00:15:50
trainee council, the recreation, scuba training council, the world
00:15:54
recreation, steward, training council. Those are the levels.
00:15:57
That's the, this almost the top boundary. There might be some
00:16:00
government regulation that sits above that depending on the
00:16:03
country you're in. And then it ends down at the individual
00:16:07
diver. Now that's the system, whether or not people have
00:16:11
control or influence about what happens within that system. Well,
00:16:14
that's, that's the way that the system has been constructed. And
00:16:18
so the way the organizations are set up is about transferring risk
00:16:23
from them liability to the lowest level possible. That's what any
00:16:28
organization would do. So the use of liability waivers, uh,
00:16:33
transfers all of those things. It's about getting the risk down
00:16:37
to the diver and or the instructor. Um, you know, your
00:16:42
point about agency standards. I have to teach to the agency
00:16:45
standards because otherwise, if something goes wrong, I'm liable.
00:16:50
Now those agency standards may not be the best that are out
00:16:55
there, but they are at a level which allows the agency to manage
00:17:00
their own individual risk. Um, by bypassing it on, you know, is it
00:17:05
achievable to do those tasks? Yes. Right. It's an instructor
00:17:08
problem. If something goes wrong, if a diver goes out on a dive
00:17:12
operation, they will nearly always sign, uh, what, depending
00:17:15
on where you are in the world, liability waiver forms. Um, and
00:17:19
now I am accepting responsibility for what happens on this dive.
00:17:24
Now, interestingly in the UK. And I think Europe, they have to
00:17:28
change the liability waiver forms because I cannot sign away my
00:17:33
right for your incompetence. Now, you know, to Sue based on that, I
00:17:38
can't Sue based on my end competence, but I can suit based
00:17:42
on your incompetence. Um, whereas a lot of international waiver
00:17:46
forms basically say, I even Sue you, if you're incompetent,
00:17:51
there's time, we'll hang on a minute. That's your
00:17:53
responsibility to look after me. So, you know, where does the
00:17:58
system, and, and start that it's about when those students are in
00:18:04
their class, teaching them about the genuine risks that exist, not
00:18:10
just about the physical risk of being underwater, but also the
00:18:14
social risks that are there. So peer pressure, or the fact that
00:18:19
we will drift, we will have this normalization of deviance and
00:18:23
Dan, or has just published a great piece in GEs in-depth blog
00:18:27
today, talking about normalization of deviance and,
00:18:31
you know, looking at the fact that it is a normal behavior to
00:18:34
go from here's my rules and I'm drifting. And I will, I will say,
00:18:40
reduce my minimum gas. I'm going to end a dive with, or exceed my
00:18:44
deck or the runtime or whatever it is. And everything goes okay,
00:18:49
or it could be having more students on a class than you're
00:18:52
supposed to because I generate more revenue that way, but things
00:18:56
don't go wrong. Therefore nobody knows what what's happening. So
00:19:00
explaining these normal human behaviors allows risk to be
00:19:05
better managed after the training course or whatever it is,
00:19:10
understanding those error producing conditions, the
00:19:14
stressors that lead us to erode the safety margins that are on,
00:19:20
um, that is not explicitly taught in the training materials that,
00:19:26
that I've had people come, my ports go, and I'm an instructor
00:19:29
for this agency and this agency, and so-and-so this isn't, it
00:19:32
might be touched on, but it is not explicitly explained. And it
00:19:37
really should be put into the training programs that are there.
00:19:41
Matt: Sure. Are you trying to get them in there? You must be.
00:19:44
Gareth: I, I am. And I have been for quite a while, and I
00:19:48
understand the resistance from their part because actually, and
00:19:53
this is often something that's forgotten is that the training
00:19:56
agencies are businesses, albeit you know, publishing houses to
00:20:02
develop training materials that then sell onto instructor,
00:20:06
trainers and instructors, and then students trying to make
00:20:10
money out of human factors based training is really difficult
00:20:15
because it doesn't actually give you anything extra. It doesn't
00:20:19
allow you to go diving any deeper. It doesn't lay to use any
00:20:22
new equipment. Um, what it does is it allows you to use your
00:20:26
brain a bit more effectively. I think also part of the resistance
00:20:31
is that the majority of the decision makers in the, the
00:20:36
training agencies have never done any training with me. So they
00:20:41
don't even know what the programs are about and how it could fit
00:20:46
into their existing training materials. So there's a bit of,
00:20:52
um, let me say genuine ignorance , um, from, from their part of
00:20:56
what it looks like and how it can fit in. And the difficulty is
00:21:00
that I'm not a diving instructor, so I don't reach any of those
00:21:04
agencies. So I don't know what the materials look like, where it
00:21:09
slot in, where you could tell a specific story about maybe
00:21:14
cognitive biases, why we make the decisions we do, or how to create
00:21:19
effective communications within a team, um, by using certain
00:21:24
techniques that are there or how a team evolves in a training
00:21:28
environment, and then how it evolves in the real world diving
00:21:32
environment and the weaknesses that, that need to be recognized
00:21:35
and dealt with. So it's a bit of a, an unknown from their side and
00:21:40
I get it, you know, that they're there to make money, um, that
00:21:44
they're not charities
00:21:45
Matt: I'm gonna, I'm gonna play devil's advocate. And, um, it
00:21:49
obviously does have a massive place in our industry, but
00:21:55
doesn't have a place in recreational dive in for your,
00:22:00
some of vacation kind of guys that dive once or twice a year
00:22:03
that can't even remember how to put their equipment together. Are
00:22:06
they going to be able to remember what, what human factors is it
00:22:09
about?
00:22:11
Gareth: Um, so actually the real benefit of if human factors is
00:22:16
taught well is it's transparent to the activities that you're
00:22:23
doing. Um, and I suppose to answer your question, is there
00:22:29
something that that can help? Yes. So at a, at a recreational
00:22:34
level is the recognition that they're fallible, that they will
00:22:37
make mistakes. That that's the first thing. Um, and then look at
00:22:43
what are the strategies for, um, making sure that we reduce the
00:22:48
likelihood and that would be doing pre dive check. You know,
00:22:51
that that's a checklist, it's making sure that the instructors
00:22:56
and the dive masters who are operating in that environment,
00:23:00
role model, correct behaviors, because the, those recreational
00:23:05
divers, if you know, they're there for a week, um, on a
00:23:08
holiday and they might be diving three or four times, they will
00:23:12
look to the instructor or the dive master, or the guide for
00:23:16
what should be being done. And if the instructors and that the
00:23:20
guides dive masters, don't do any pre dive checks. You know, the,
00:23:25
the, uh, the clients will then turn around and go, Oh, cool.
00:23:28
When you get to be really good, you don't have to do checks,
00:23:32
whereas actually the other way round. So it's, it's how you
00:23:35
influence others. So it doesn't have to be pure directive and
00:23:41
part of the lesson, but it can be influenced and role model by
00:23:47
behaviors, by others within the, or by others within the, this
00:23:51
sort of system that, that the dive center or, or the liverboard
00:23:54
or whatever.
00:23:55
Matt: And to be honest, I mean, you touched on one of my pet
00:23:58
hates, there is people not setting up their own equipment
00:24:01
and not know how to do it properly. And I spent a year in
00:24:04
two fi in Papua New Guinea, and every diver that came to visit
00:24:08
and dive with us, had to do their own equipment sets up before they
00:24:12
go on the boat just the first time. And then the boys would
00:24:15
take over and they could check as the boys go. But just for my own
00:24:19
sanity and sanitization, you do your own gear and you would be
00:24:23
amazed at how many guests would complain because they have to do
00:24:28
their own equipment. And then the humility, when they realize that
00:24:32
they don't know how to do their own equipment, because they've
00:24:34
not done it for so long now, surely that answered an inherent
00:24:38
problem. That's going on in our industry already with trying to
00:24:41
be too customer Carey. And, you know, um, and again, for the
00:24:49
guests that are assuming everything's going to be done for
00:24:51
them now leads me onto another little point. We were discussing
00:24:54
a couple of days ago, and that's the, um, I'm going to go on a
00:24:58
little rant now, um, assumption and, uh, Dougal, Windsor Wilson
00:25:04
on Facebook. He asks about assumptions as well. And the
00:25:07
assumptions from the guests there that that dive guide is going to
00:25:10
do everything for them. It is my pet hate that people expect a
00:25:15
dive pro to look after them on the boat, under the water. If
00:25:20
there's any emergencies, the diaper is going to sort it out.
00:25:22
And then if anything goes wrong, the dive bros, asphalt and all of
00:25:28
this stuff, and I don't want to rent too much. All of this stuff
00:25:31
is in my opinion, what you are trying to get clarification on
00:25:37
for the world and get it set straight, where everyone
00:25:40
everyone's in their own little box, everyone works as a team.
00:25:43
Everyone knows how everything should and does happen. And then
00:25:47
we've got clarity, hopefully.
00:25:50
Gareth: Yeah. So, you know, going right back to, where does the
00:25:54
system begin if you think about where those divers have got those
00:26:00
assumptions and those behaviors from is when they would have been
00:26:04
learned to dive and as guests, they will have been given the
00:26:09
minimum amount of instruction time, um, to set up their gear.
00:26:16
It would have been demoed, and then they would have been, you
00:26:20
know, stuffed would have been done for them. Tick, you've done
00:26:22
that skill. You've put your reg on the cylinder, you put your BC
00:26:26
on the cylinder, right? Done. You've demonstrated you can do
00:26:30
that skill. Now we've got people who will do that for you. So all
00:26:33
you need to do is pitch up, listen to some lectures, you
00:26:36
know, again, sweeping generalizations, listen to some
00:26:39
lectures, watch some videos, get on the boat, go out to the dive
00:26:43
site. And, you know, you get fed and watered and treated nicely.
00:26:47
You get kitted up, people help you with, with what's going on.
00:26:51
And then you jump in and somebody is going to shepherd you. And so,
00:26:54
you know, a lot of that, that initial diver training and
00:26:58
development, you will have an instructor with you, or you have
00:27:01
a guide with your dive master with you. And there isn't the
00:27:05
clarity that says you are responsible for your activities.
00:27:11
I'm paying you a shed load of money to take me diving. Then I'm
00:27:15
taking you to the dive site and you have that. So there is this
00:27:20
looking at, how does it make sense for somebody write it? I'm
00:27:24
going to say the sharp end as a term from the safety world, the
00:27:27
person who's right at the coalface, you know, doing stuff,
00:27:31
how does it make sense for them to do what they did? Well, if you
00:27:33
look back at their experiential journey and, and how they
00:27:37
developed and, and how they got to where they are, that's, that's
00:27:41
why they behave the way they do and why?
00:27:44
Matt: Well, I've got to pick on you. You did say it's a sweeping
00:27:47
statement. It is a big sweeping statement because there's a lot
00:27:50
of instructors out there that are very, very good and very
00:27:53
meticulous at what they do. But over time you add in skill fade
00:27:58
and the ignorance of, you know, future guests and liverboards,
00:28:03
and, and, you know, more lackadaisical dive professionals,
00:28:07
then yeah, it will creep in, but I just wanted to make sure we
00:28:11
don't get shot down in flames there that all professionals.
00:28:15
Gareth: Yeah. And so, yeah, I totally agree. And there are lots
00:28:20
of professionals out there, and actually we only hear about the
00:28:24
negative outcomes that are there. They, you know, they have a, uh,
00:28:29
a disproportional effect to our understanding, and that's a
00:28:33
cognitive bias. You know, we have a recall or a recency effect
00:28:37
where if something happens and it's got emotional, significant,
00:28:41
emotional, um, baggage associated with it, we'll be able to recall
00:28:45
it more easily. And, you know, going back to defending the
00:28:49
organizations, numerically, statistically diving is pretty
00:28:54
safe. You've probably got more chance of being killed or injured
00:28:57
driving to the dive site than you do on the dive. Now that doesn't
00:29:03
mean we shouldn't improve what goes on in diving, but if you
00:29:07
look at it from an organizational point of view of how much risk
00:29:11
are we willing to tolerate? Well, that's a, that's a sound number.
00:29:16
Now, you won't get any of the organizations to tell you what
00:29:19
that, uh, you know, as low as reasonably practicable number is
00:29:24
because that would be, you know, commercial, reputational, suicide
00:29:27
to say, yes, we're happy with a fatality rate of X, uh, in, in
00:29:32
those sectors. And to be honest, it's not our problem. We've given
00:29:36
them the standards off they go. Um, so, you know, we go back to
00:29:41
transparency, risk management again. Yeah.
00:29:44
Matt: Now, um, I know you've had a struggle all the way along the
00:29:48
journey so far bringing this into the dive industry, but I've got
00:29:51
to ask when you released the book, you must have seen quite a
00:29:55
significant upturn of interest. It seems to explode when you, uh,
00:30:01
when you released that book.
00:30:04
Gareth: Yeah. And so I'd been struggling. So I suppose the
00:30:07
journey started in 2010 11, where I wrote a white paper looking
00:30:15
about diving incident reporting and, um, safety management in the
00:30:20
UK diving industry. And, and it went down like a bit of a lead
00:30:23
balloon. Um, and shortly after that, I started a PhD part-time
00:30:28
self funded PhD. Um, and the struggle there was, nobody was
00:30:35
really interested in what I was doing. My goal was to try and
00:30:40
produce something like a, um, something that happens in
00:30:43
aviation, where they've got a structure, which looks at
00:30:45
organizational failures, supervisory failures, individual
00:30:50
failures, where we set ourselves up. So we're tired, or we're not
00:30:52
prepared or things like, and then there's the act of failure. So we
00:30:55
make a slip or a mistake or a lapse, or we, we break a rule. So
00:31:00
that went on for about six years. And in the end I stopped doing it
00:31:04
because I was spending money. I wasn't getting anywhere, but in
00:31:07
January, 2016, I ran the first face-to-face training program
00:31:15
that developed, um, as a pilot that went well, another one in
00:31:18
February, another one in April. And then somebody said, well, why
00:31:22
don't you do the pre-learning that's there and set it up as a
00:31:25
standalone course. And I got some traction there as people doing
00:31:29
online learning and got some really positive feedback from
00:31:32
people saying, look, this stuff is, you know, should be in the
00:31:35
training materials. And it wasn't until probably the spring of 18
00:31:41
where I was running a face-to-face class. And somebody
00:31:44
had said, why don't you write a book about this? Because people
00:31:47
will consume it as a book rather than doing online materials. So I
00:31:52
had thought about that. So then they spent the next probably from
00:31:56
the summer four or five months in, in the summer of 18 writing
00:32:01
it, and then the next sort of six months getting it edited and
00:32:06
turned around and things like that. And I'd spent a fair amount
00:32:11
of time trying, you know, three marketing training of how do I
00:32:15
market this, because it's a really difficult topic to market
00:32:19
because I was trying to do it from a safety perspective. And
00:32:23
you never market, um, away from a threat. What you do is you Mark
00:32:29
it towards a benefit because it's what people will want, not what
00:32:34
people are trying to get away from. Right. Um, so I'd spent a
00:32:37
lot of time how to try and market this. So I spent the total end of
00:32:43
18 marketing the book and getting the first two chapters out there
00:32:50
so people could go on. So I had a pretty big list by the time the
00:32:56
book was released in March 19. And I spent a lot of time
00:33:01
packaging up and signing books and posting them out. And then it
00:33:05
starts getting into the hands of, you know, it's a terrible term
00:33:09
influences and not just in the sort of sports diving industry,
00:33:13
but in the scientific and the military and the commercial, and
00:33:17
actually people in traditional safety as well. We'll pick it up
00:33:21
and go, Oh, hang on. This is really good. And then it starts
00:33:24
spreading out. So yeah, the, the rise was, was, was really nice to
00:33:30
see because it's like, yes, there is, there is value being created
00:33:34
out there. Yeah. What I write in the books now, though, is
00:33:38
knowledge is not enough. We must apply willing is not enough. We
00:33:42
must do. Um, and, and it's attributed to Bruce leave that
00:33:46
came from God before that we'll go to, um, and you know, it's
00:33:51
great. I read this now, do something with it. I mean, that
00:33:56
means I have to change what I change to change requires a bit
00:34:00
of effort and energy and things like that. But starting to get
00:34:03
people to talk about things is it's been huge benefit.
00:34:07
Matt: Yeah. And is it, um, is the way forward to, um, introduce
00:34:13
human factors to the newer divers, the younger divers, the
00:34:17
ones that are more accepted, uh, that more, they're more keen to,
00:34:24
to absorb the information that's going to help them progress
00:34:28
rather than the, the ones that might be stuck in their ways and
00:34:31
find it difficult to introduce that change.
00:34:35
Gareth: Um, so actually I've now got five other instructors who
00:34:39
are, so it's not just me. I've got, um, I've got two in the
00:34:43
States or two in Canada at the moment. Um, I got one in Belgium
00:34:47
Holland, I've got one in Egypt and, um, our traveler and one of
00:34:54
the UAE. So they, they do some of that sort of the sharing site.
00:34:59
And actually they're all with the exception of one, they're all
00:35:02
diving instructors. So they give me ideas of where this could fit
00:35:07
in. So there is a, uh, a multi-pronged approach. One is to
00:35:12
go in and try and simplify it at the, um, probably the, the rescue
00:35:19
diver dive master level, um, to try and get some interest there,
00:35:24
to get some interest at the, in the se tech, curious, those
00:35:29
people are sitting there going right, what what's tech diving
00:35:31
about. Um, and so we're talking about kit and depth and insight,
00:35:36
actually, a lot of it's about in your head, uh, and, and how to
00:35:39
make more effective decisions and how to recognize that you're
00:35:43
going to expose yourself to greater risk and an understanding
00:35:47
and practicing the stuff that's in the book helps mitigate and
00:35:51
control some of those. And then the other bit is going in at the
00:35:55
sort of experienced instructors. Again, we go back to the
00:36:00
influencer term to get them to start even just using the
00:36:05
language. Once we start changing words, we can change worlds. And
00:36:10
that's not my quote. That's somebody else's, I forgot it's
00:36:13
shrunk, but is you, you change the language. Um, and people will
00:36:18
start changing their own behaviors accordingly. Um, and
00:36:23
I've seen that probably over the last two or three years, and
00:36:27
being in bigger Facebook groups where there's this concept of
00:36:33
local rationality, how does it make sense for people to do what
00:36:37
they did? And now I see other people posting those same bits or
00:36:42
they'll tag me in, Oh, it's great. You know, um, and I'll add
00:36:46
a little bit of extra, but the fact that people are now able to
00:36:51
gonna say, fight those battles, using stuff that I've given is
00:36:56
incredibly rewarding and it will, it will start cascading out, but
00:37:00
it's, it's a huge journey to, to go on. Um, and I I'm, I'm, I'm up
00:37:07
for it
00:37:07
Matt: And it, well, it's, it's not gonna stop growing, is it, I
00:37:10
mean, you're, you've, you've mentioned you've got five, um,
00:37:13
instructors. Oh yeah. Give him a shout out.
00:37:20
Gareth: So there's the five instructors I've got at the
00:37:22
moment and there's four in training and waiting for them to
00:37:25
sign off. So the five instructors, Guy Shockey who's in
00:37:28
Vancouver, there's Helen Pellerin . Who's in Quebec, there's Bart
00:37:32
Den Ouden, who's in the Netherlands. And then Jenny Lord
00:37:36
in Dahab and Daryl Owen is in the UAE. And I got four others who,
00:37:41
and that's Meredith Tanguay who's in Florida. Uh, Chris Tomlin, a
00:37:45
UK, uh, Beatrice Rivara in Italy and Mike Mason, who's up in
00:37:51
Newcastle. So two weeks ago we were supposed to be running the
00:37:54
certifying workshops, but obviously COVID has knocked that
00:37:59
on the head. So I'm hoping as soon as we can start traveling, I
00:38:03
can get to, uh, to certify them. And then there'll be four more
00:38:06
instructors able to, to deliver the materials. Okay.
00:38:09
Matt: So we're going to have nine , nine global instructors. That's
00:38:12
it, that's a hefty run from when was the book released 2019, was
00:38:17
it? And then we've had a year if we can exclude last year because
00:38:22
we didn't do anything.
00:38:23
Gareth: Well, interestingly, didn't do anything face to face.
00:38:27
But to me COVID actually was a bit of a, a blessing in disguise
00:38:32
because people were in stuck at home going[inaudible] and I'd
00:38:36
already started in 2000 tail end of 2019, delivering a webinar
00:38:42
based 10 week program. Um, and since then I've delivered six of
00:38:48
those. So there's about 200 people, um, have gone through
00:38:55
some training, um, since, you know, since the, by the online
00:38:59
webinar basis. Um, so, and they then speak and, uh, I'll give a
00:39:04
shout out to Mateas, uh, who's down in Victoria. Um, he's
00:39:10
changed the, the culture of his club having come on a course with
00:39:13
me last year and gone, ah, this is blow my mind. I can't stop
00:39:18
thinking about it. I'm going to take this stuff. And they got rid
00:39:23
of the wooden weight belt award within their club, which was
00:39:27
about the biggest or most embarrassing screw up. Somebody
00:39:30
had done the previous year. And he said, let, just really
00:39:33
demeaning. This is, you know, yes, it's funny, but nobody's
00:39:37
really happy to receive this. So he stopped that and I said, well
00:39:42
, you could still turn it around. You could still issue a prize,
00:39:45
but do it for the biggest learning experience of the year
00:39:49
when it comes to diving. Um, and now you've, you've recognized the
00:39:54
learning that's happening in the club. So really proud of
00:40:00
[inaudible]
00:40:01
Matt: Victoria as in Australia. Yeah,
00:40:03
Gareth: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. In Melbourne
00:40:06
Matt: I'll come and have a dive. I've not dived Melbourne yet. And
00:40:08
I keep itching to do it every time I go there. It's just not
00:40:10
long enough to be there. Yeah. Itching, my tests. I'll come
00:40:13
diving with you and I don't want the wooden belt.
00:40:20
Gareth: Well, then you can have the best learning experience that
00:40:22
would go positive thing. Yeah.
00:40:24
Matt: Yeah. Um, well, as soon as we're talking about Australia and
00:40:30
you're obviously in the UK and we've mentioned Canada America on
00:40:32
the kind of thing. Um, one thing I've noticed with, with work in a
00:40:35
dive in, in various locations around the world now is that when
00:40:40
you go to particular countries, they have a different kind of
00:40:44
take on how you should be diving now, by that, I mean, um,
00:40:50
Thailand, some people will moan about it, say it's bit blahzay.
00:40:55
Well, it's not, um, those places that are, uh, very dense
00:41:00
population of people going through basic training, the
00:41:04
courses tend to be run quite tight because they've got to be
00:41:08
up to standard with everyone else who's producing. Um, conversely
00:41:13
you come to Australia and, um, I was, he's a pretty laid back and,
00:41:18
you know, take everything in stride. Um, and I find it quite
00:41:22
shocking to see how many people go solo dive in just off the
00:41:26
shoreline air, um, with no redundant as supplies. And it
00:41:31
just seems to be the norm. I find that quite frightening, but I
00:41:38
think there's gotta be a place there for, I think we mentioned
00:41:41
it, the what'd you call it the other day called culture or
00:41:43
cultural differences, cultural awareness yet, have you, have you
00:41:47
experienced much of that so far going through the training and
00:41:49
the, the guys that you've been doing these courses with?
00:41:53
Gareth: Not necessarily because there are self-selecting audience
00:42:00
that, that comes on the, the training programs anyway, so that
00:42:04
then they're the early adopters. So the people who see that, the
00:42:07
benefit of self-development, um, what I have seen is, um, a little
00:42:17
bit about, I haven't done much out in the, in, you know, I've
00:42:21
done some training in New Zealand and Australia, I've done one
00:42:24
session in Bali, but they were all sort of ex-pats that are,
00:42:28
were in Bali. So they weren't really indicative of the culture
00:42:33
that's there. Um, in, in Europe, there are certainly different, um
00:42:39
, behaviors between sort of countries. Um, so it's certainly
00:42:46
an area that needs to be looked at in terms of incidents, but I
00:42:50
don't think I haven't really encountered it myself. Now, what
00:42:54
I did find interesting were your comment about Thailand. So here's
00:42:57
a cognitive bias straight away is that my, my perception of
00:43:02
learning to dive out in Thailand is not great because it's about
00:43:07
getting people through the door as quickly as possible. And the
00:43:10
driving factor is more about money than quality because of the
00:43:16
clientele that you're likely to be training in the day. They want
00:43:20
a bucket ticket, you know, bucket list ticket that says done
00:43:23
diving, move on. Yeah, yeah. And the, you know, the, the w I don't
00:43:32
know whether or not your use of the word tight meant tight as
00:43:35
they enter the high quality and they were having to compete, or
00:43:38
whether or not they were tight because they were running back to
00:43:40
back courses. And so they couldn't, um, th there's no flex
00:43:45
for somebody who's not quite good enough to have some extra dives,
00:43:50
but I find sign off and off you go. Um, so yeah, there is a huge
00:43:56
amount that that needs to be taken into account in culture. So
00:43:59
go back to your book, rumble, rumble, rumble, go back to your
00:44:01
point that solar dive in Australia, look at the system and
00:44:05
, and the, how the, the local culture will change risk
00:44:10
perceptions, and what can be done to do that. So if you know that
00:44:17
something is lacking in an output where you need to change what the
00:44:23
input is. So it's that the instructors, if they're not happy
00:44:27
about people solo diving, because that's the norm. Well, actually
00:44:31
there needs to be more emphasis on teamwork and shared mental
00:44:35
models and not relying, but working together as a team during
00:44:40
the training program, because if it's not emphasized, then most
00:44:44
courses are individuals who come together as a group learn, and
00:44:49
they go off, they don't interact and operate together as a team,
00:44:53
and you can do that to recreation level. It just requires the
00:44:56
instructor to up their game and up their knowledge and their
00:44:59
skills to be able to teach that. So, um, and you know, the fact
00:45:05
that they don't take redundant air supplies with them. Well, if
00:45:08
that's not something that's been emphasized or taught or brought
00:45:12
up in training, don't be surprised that people don't do it
00:45:16
outside of the training because you know, and their argument,
00:45:20
well, they should know about these risks. They can learn from
00:45:23
others. Well, then we get into the social conformance piece.
00:45:26
Well, everybody else is diving without redundant air. Why do I
00:45:31
need to, because they're not all dropping like flies, therefore it
00:45:35
must be safe. So these are all bits of the human factors, jigsaw
00:45:40
, jigsaw puzzle that needs to be taken into account. Oh, it's huge
00:45:47
. It's huge. And I think this is, you know, the human factors is,
00:45:52
is general and approach and specific in application. And by
00:45:56
that, I mean, cognitive biases, social interactions, the way we
00:46:00
make decisions, Lehman make communications. There's a huge
00:46:04
body of research that explains how this works, but how to create
00:46:08
change at an individual level or a team level or a dive center
00:46:12
level has to be specific. So I I'm much better at answering
00:46:18
specific problem type questions than writing something generic
00:46:23
because you write something generic people go that doesn't
00:46:26
apply to me. That doesn't apply to me. That's another bias that
00:46:29
we have, you know, that they're different to me. So it doesn't
00:46:33
apply to me well, hanging on it. Why is it any different? But I
00:46:37
have got examples of being in Southeast Asia where authority,
00:46:43
or, or the social culture, which is normally termed as a sort of
00:46:46
authority gradient where a junior diver or an experienced diver
00:46:50
won't question, a more senior person. Yeah. But it's not as
00:46:54
simple as just this seniority piece. It's about respect. And we
00:47:01
are a family that actually we're going to, we wouldn't question
00:47:06
our fathers or uncles, or, you know, the patriarch set up
00:47:11
because they might give me something later on. And so you
00:47:16
get to be in situations. And I know instructors who operate out
00:47:19
there where they will, um, fail something on the leader, the team
00:47:24
leader, the dive is going on and the rest of the team, or they
00:47:27
will get the leader to make a mistake. And the rest of the team
00:47:30
will just sit there and not question or challenge what's
00:47:33
going on. And so there's, there's a huge learning that's needed for
00:47:37
the instructors to understand these behaviors and come up with
00:47:42
strategies to inform their students that says, look, once
00:47:46
you're out of the, the cover and the protection of an
00:47:50
instructional setting, you're out on your own. And that means that
00:47:55
you have to be aware of these. And if things do go wrong, you
00:47:58
have to say something before it becomes catastrophic. So it's,
00:48:03
yeah, it's a, it's a huge jigsaw puzzle.
00:48:06
Matt: Yeah. Yeah. Uh, how much that man, I'm sitting here
00:48:08
listening to you and just thinking back over what we've
00:48:11
discussed over the last, however long, and it's an awkward topic.
00:48:16
I mean, we've got to say it is an awkward topic to talk about. And
00:48:19
especially, I mean, I'm, I'm, I'm not forwarding, I'm not shy in
00:48:23
coming forward and speaking what I want to speak. Um, but I found
00:48:28
myself second, you know, thinking twice thinking before I speak,
00:48:33
which is not usually me. Um, so I think I can now understand a
00:48:39
little bit more why it takes 10 weeks of webinars to get this
00:48:43
training across because you've got some, some massive voids to
00:48:47
cross. And so a lot of barriers to break down for this to be a
00:48:52
success.
00:48:54
Gareth: Oh, totally. And, you know, I look at where aviation,
00:48:58
you know, started in the eighties because they were blaming pilots
00:49:02
for pilot error, sticking the aircraft in the ground because
00:49:05
they were not paying attention or miscommunicating and ropes wrong
00:49:10
selections, but ultimately boiled down to pilot error. And it
00:49:13
wasn't until they started looking at the cockpit voice reporters
00:49:16
and the flight data recorders. And they said, well, hang on a
00:49:19
minute. They, they, there was an awareness of what was going on,
00:49:22
but they were unable to share that picture amongst the rest of
00:49:26
the crew. And when they did, it was potentially too late. And
00:49:29
then they start looking at, well, hang on with it. The errors
00:49:32
didn't just happen in the cockpit. They would have been
00:49:36
developed from the aircraft design or air traffic controls,
00:49:39
design, or airport design, and start looking further back up. So
00:49:43
you start taking a systems view about what's going on. So even
00:49:47
though aviation has been doing this for 40 plus years, 50 years
00:49:51
or so, they still have issues and they still have, you know,
00:49:56
aircraft crashes, they still have miscommunication issues, all of
00:50:00
those things. And that's an incredibly regulated industry.
00:50:04
Healthcare has been doing it for probably about 15 years and they
00:50:08
really struggle, um, because of the dynamic environment, the
00:50:12
pressures and the social cultural issues that exist in, in a
00:50:15
healthcare environment. Um, and in the UK, they're starting to
00:50:19
bring some formal structure to human factors into the clinical
00:50:24
environment based on work by a guy called Martin Bromley. Um,
00:50:30
who's formed the clinical human factors group as a way of trying
00:50:33
to get that. And there's now governmental support to, to what
00:50:35
they're doing and, and the colleges that surgeons needs,
00:50:38
tests, dentists, whatever. And now starting to put stuff
00:50:41
together, um, in the diving industry, it's, it's me and
00:50:46
abandon followers who are going, this is a good idea. We need to
00:50:49
do it. Um, and, and I get the resistance there. Aren't dead
00:50:53
bodies lying up. Therefore it must be okay.
00:50:57
Matt: Yeah. Yeah. Well, I didn't say right. I suppose I didn't
00:51:01
right at the start of this bloody episode, to be honest, Eva,
00:51:05
you're 25 years in the air force. You're actually a navigator,
00:51:08
wouldn't you? Yeah.
00:51:10
Gareth: Yeah. Hercules navigator in a multi-crew environment and
00:51:13
then went on and did a master's in aerospace systems, which is
00:51:17
where my knowledge of human factors and sort of the deeper
00:51:21
knowledge. And that's when I sort of started digging deeper and
00:51:24
then went into flight trials, um, with Airbus. So picked up some
00:51:29
human factors stuff there, then worked in research and
00:51:32
development and then worked in procurement and systems
00:51:34
engineering. So very broad view of the world. And it was during
00:51:39
the, the latter sort of five years of my time in the air
00:51:41
force. That's not in PhD. Um, so yeah, huge breadth.
00:51:48
Matt: I'll just get a psych, a anyone, any of the divers that
00:51:50
are out there. Thank you. I'm not gonna listen to this fellow. He's
00:51:52
not even, he's not even a professional. He's not even an
00:51:53
instructor. Well, I think you kind of top it for, um, you know,
00:51:57
having experienced in a structured, uh, work environment
00:52:01
and how teamwork comes together.
00:52:04
Gareth: Yeah. And so, yeah, and from the diving side of the
00:52:09
majority of my training has gone through gue. Um, so I did
00:52:14
fundamentals in 2006. Uh, we're only had about 40 dives to my
00:52:21
name. So I was, I was really lucky that I didn't have to
00:52:24
unlearn a bunch of stuff. Um, and then since then, um, I've
00:52:29
probably got about 800 dives, uh , certified at the highest levels
00:52:33
to, you know, my highest levels of GV take two, which is, uh, an
00:52:37
advanced tronics course and, uh, JJ rebreather, which I'm going to
00:52:43
get recertified on the end of may , um, to get back up to speed on
00:52:48
that. So, but I know there was a question about rebreathers.
00:52:52
Matt: Yeah. That was, um, uh, Lisa, Lisa, Marie. Yeah. Um, what
00:52:58
are your thoughts on rebreathers then? That was a, that's a whole
00:53:01
new,
00:53:04
Gareth: My view on rebreathers. Um, are they safe? Are they
00:53:08
unsafe? Uh, a piece of equipment is not unsafe in of itself. And
00:53:15
it's a simple example is a hairdryer could be safe. It's not
00:53:20
particularly safe. You sit in a bath and put the hairdryer in the
00:53:23
water with you. Um, and, and so it's this need to look at a
00:53:28
system again. So rebreathers have been designed to the level that
00:53:35
the, um, the market will support. And by that, I mean, is it costs
00:53:42
manufacturers money to design builds, certify, and they've got
00:53:46
to recoup that money. And then they've got to make a profit.
00:53:49
Otherwise they're not a valid, sustainable business. So the
00:53:54
diving community won't pay much more than they pay or ready, um,
00:54:01
for, for what's there. So in terms of maturity and equipment
00:54:05
set, it's probably, you know, there are little nuances, but
00:54:08
it's probably about as mature as it's going to get. Then we look
00:54:13
at the other pieces of the system and that's the training agencies,
00:54:16
the instructors and the divers themselves, um, and how they all
00:54:22
come together is how to create a safe diving, converter, calm, a
00:54:26
safe diving operation on a rebreather and recognize that
00:54:32
it's working together that creates safety, not a reboot.
00:54:38
Rebreather is unsafe. The difficulty is that there is,
00:54:42
again, there is no formal training that goes into agency
00:54:45
training materials that talk about human fallibility and
00:54:49
cognitive biases, and why checklists are designed the way
00:54:53
they are. They could probably be improved, um, to make them, you
00:54:57
know, to have less friction, um, to be in a situation that you
00:55:02
operate as a team. And if one of the team isn't using a checklist
00:55:09
that you've created the environment that actually, if I'm
00:55:11
not using a checklist, I expect you to call me out. And if you
00:55:15
are not using one, I'm going to call you out. And there is no,
00:55:19
there's nothing wrong with that, but it's, it's, it's not easy
00:55:24
because those, those soft bits are not easy to measure. Um, it's
00:55:30
much easier to measure simple compliance when you're delivering
00:55:33
a course, but that doesn't necessarily help you, um, develop
00:55:38
competencies and attitudes. And the, the final piece then is the
00:55:43
expectation that if you haven't read, reached a standard, then
00:55:47
you don't get a certification. Now I know some agencies put that
00:55:52
in the hands of the instructor that says, are they, have, they
00:55:56
got the right attitude to dive this equipment? If not, then you
00:55:59
can refuse certification. That has to be explained really
00:56:04
clearly before the course starts, because otherwise you're going to
00:56:08
end up with a whole world of hurt that says, hang in there. I
00:56:11
matched all the skills and it's just your opinion that I'm not
00:56:15
safe. And so, you know, you end up with conflict there. Yeah. So
00:56:20
to answer the question, Lisa, my view is they are a valid too, and
00:56:24
they're potentially safer than open circuit at certain depths.
00:56:29
Um, how have you also need to train in shallower debts to be
00:56:32
able to go to the deeper depths, to, to be competent when things
00:56:36
go wrong and you also need to have the attitude that says this
00:56:40
thing can fail. I need to know what it's doing all the time, and
00:56:44
I can resolve those failures. And that means I need to go and
00:56:47
practice them. And there's nothing wrong with doing drills
00:56:51
in a quarry in the shallows to make sure that you're competent
00:56:55
to deal with almost no notice failures, because those failures,
00:57:00
if we knew they were going to come, we'd do something about
00:57:03
them.
00:57:04
Matt: For sure. I mean, it's gotta be second nature. And the
00:57:06
only way you're gonna be able to do that is through training.
00:57:10
Gareth: Yeah. W with effective feedback. Yeah.
00:57:12
Matt: Yeah. Happy days we've been going on for quite some time now.
00:57:18
So it must be time for your breakfast and time for me to have
00:57:21
a beer. So it's been an absolute pleasure mate. How can people
00:57:24
just get in touch with, with you and where can they find you
00:57:27
online? We'll put them in the show notes as well, but give them
00:57:29
a call.
00:57:29
Gareth: Yeah. So the easiest way is the human diver.com. Um, and,
00:57:35
uh, that there's a contact page there that, that sends out a form
00:57:38
through to me. Um, so that that's the easiest bit. There's a
00:57:42
Facebook page as well, or a Facebook group rather we've got
00:57:46
about six and a half thousand people in which if you just, uh,
00:57:49
searching Facebook for human factors in diving, then you will
00:57:53
, uh, you'll find that. And I'd really recommend anybody who
00:57:58
wants to learn more about human factors in a, in a 30 minute
00:58:04
documentary is to go onto the human diver website, go to the
00:58:08
top and look at if only click the link there and watch a
00:58:12
documentary, which will bring a tear to some people's eyes,
00:58:17
because it deals with a fatality. And it deals with raw emotion
00:58:20
that the dive team that lost a member. And it's told the story
00:58:25
is told through a lens of human factors and adjust culture, which
00:58:28
is about understanding how it made sense for somebody to do
00:58:32
what they did. There are also some additional notes. So if
00:58:35
you're inclined to take this further, there is a guide that
00:58:39
explains the event in more details and also teaches you how
00:58:42
to run a workshop on how to learn more about, or learn from, um,
00:58:50
the, uh, the documentary, if only, and you can get the book
00:58:53
from that from the website as well, or from Amazon.
00:58:56
Matt: Well, we'll put it all in the show notes. If you want to,
00:58:58
if you want to put a link to this on your website, feel free and
00:59:01
people can listen to it. I haven't already, and I'll put a
00:59:03
few links in for that. Um, if only DACA. Yeah. I'll put that
00:59:07
into the show notes as well. So they've got direct link to you
00:59:09
there. Um, Gareth has been awesome. Um, let's do it again,
00:59:14
some point, especially with all these new instructors that are
00:59:16
coming through, we can put something together and, yeah.
00:59:21
Gareth: Excellent. Thanks very much, Matt, and, uh, have fun to
00:59:23
everybody. Thanks so much. Thanks very much.
00:59:26
Matt: Uh, goodbye. Everybody podcast for the inquisitive diver
00:59:32
.